Various body parts, including the head, arms, hands, torso, hips and legs, play different roles in tango. Tango dancers must understand the different functions of the body parts and properly assign attention in order to use them in a controlled and coordinate fashion. Incorrect use of the body parts is a common problem in tango.
In close embrace, the woman may rest her head on the man's temple, cheek or chin according to her height. She may choose not to do so, but if she does, then the touch of the head must be comfortable. Some women prop their head against the man's head in order to prevent their breasts from touching his chest. Beginners often draw support from the head when doing steps. Such practices reflect a misunderstanding of the function of the head. The touch of the head is a sign of intimacy and must be gentle. Dancers need to dissociate the head from the body and not use it against the partner to avoid chest contact or to assist the movement of the body, as both are uncomfortable.
The functions of the arms and hands are more complex. Arms and hands can be used to hold the partner to form an intimate and comforting embrace. They can also be used to support, protect and sooth the partner. These are the correct uses of the arms and hands. Arms and hands can also be used to convey intentions and to fight. Some people hence use them to coerce or resist the partner, wrestle with the partner, spread the partner away to avoid intimacy, hold on to the partner for balance and stability, or grab the partner to assist the movement of the body. These are misuses of the arms and hands. Beginners need to rid the habit of using arms and hands. Tango is led and followed with the torsos. Arms and hands should only be used to form a snug embrace, not as the tool to lead and follow, to keep balance and stability, to distance oneself from the partner, or to assist the movement of the body, let alone to resist or fight with the partner. The touch of the arms and hands should be gentle and weightless. Dancers must dissociate their arms and hands from their body and not use them as weapons or movement aids.
The torso is the command center in tango dancing. Tango dancers use their torsos to communicate intentions and feelings, and to bring out the movements of the hips and legs. Tango is an intimate and feeling-oriented dance mainly because of the role the torso plays in the dance. Unfortunately, this role of the torso is often overlooked by action-oriented dancers who use an open dance hold to replace the embrace, putting the torso to petty use under the command of the arms and hands. As a result, they changed tango from a feeling-oriented dance to a movement-oriented dance.
In a previous post I quoted a young woman's insightful observation on tango (see The Fourteenth Pitffall of a Tangura). What she called the first layer technique, namely, to maintain a comfortable embrace, and the second layer technique, namely, to pursue visual beauty, in essence refer to the function of the torso and the function of the legs respectively. In tango, the torso is in relative rest in the embrace, but the movements of the legs are brisk and colorful. If the torso is associated with feelings, then the legs represent beauty. A good tango is a perfect combination of the two. Formalist dancers concern only about the look and ignore the feelings, and they use the torso as but another limb to create fancy movements under the command of the arms and hands. However, pursuing visual impression at the expense of the intimacy and comfort of the embrace is not worth the candle. Throughout its history from tango milonguero to tango Villa Urquiza to tango fantasia to tango Nuevo, the alienation of tango clearly follows an aesthetic path farther and farther away from the embrace and feelings (see The Styles of Tango). I do not think that direction is worth advocating. I believe the juxtaposition of the comfort of the embrace and the beauty of the footwork is totally possible. It does not have to sacrifice the embrace in order to pursue beauty. Many beautiful tangos danced by outstanding tango dancers, such as the Poema danced by Geraldine Rojas and Javier Rodrigues, and many tangos danced by Agustina Piggio and Carlotos Espinoza, are good examples.
These dancers can achieve such level of excellence because they are versed in using their hips, which are like the swivel that joins the upper body and the lower body. Because their torsos are connected in the embrace, they need to swivel their hips in order to move their legs around each other. In tango terms this is called dissociation. Educated tango dancers are able to dissociate their upper body and lower body to a greater degree, so they can step freely around each other without breaking the embrace. Dissociation is not only a physical detachment but also an artistic division of labor, enabling the upper body to remain in the comfort of the embrace while allowing the lower body to maximize its creativity.
In contrast, the body of the novice is not flexible enough to be dissociated freely, so, instead of using their torsos to lead and follow, an inexperienced man often leads with his arms and hands, and an inexperienced woman tends to turn her whole body instead of swiveling her hips, and they grip hold of each other with their hands to help themselves with the movements, causing the rupture of the embrace and incoherence of the dance. You may call it by its fine-sounding name "open embrace," but its real cause is the inability to dance in close embrace, thus resort to a fake substitute instead. But, cheating has a price, as it can only fool others, not the dancers themselves. Professional dancers use open embrace on stage to perform for the audience, not for their own pleasure. They pay that price for their job. As soon as they go to a milonga, they switch to dance in close embrace (see Social Tango and Performance Tango). Novices who envy their glamour on stage, blindly imitate them in the milongas without even can embrace well. Such crude imitation only makes them look foolish.
To sum up, when dancing tango, the head and the arms and hands should be completely relaxed and not interfere with the movement of the body. The function of the torso is to communicate intentions and feelings via direct torso contact and to bring out the movement of the lower body. Tango's beautiful footwork is the function of the legs. The key to maximize the beauty of the footwork while maintaining the comfort of the embrace lies in the swivel of the hips. Learning tango is not primarily learning steps, but learning to control, coordinate and properly use various parts of the body. Focusing on the steps and ignoring feelings is the leading course of misuse of the body parts in tango.
Thanks for this very interesting post.
ReplyDeletePaul Yang wrote:
... pursuing visual impression at the expense of the intimacy and comfort of the embrace is not worth the candle...
This is indeed true where the activity in question is social dancing rather than performance meant to entertain or impress an audience. I am thus a little taken aback by your choice of illustrative video clips. Both celebrity couples are first and foremost performers and, though a close embrace is maintained, their dances are marked by many of the uncomfortable exhibition features that far too many social dancers try to ape. One need only observe the straining position of the woman’s left arm with splayed fingers in both videos. Beautiful (as a performance) this may be for some. A model for comfortable social dancing, it most certainly is not.
Paul wrote: "Many beautiful tangos danced by outstanding tango dancers, such as the Poema danced by Geraldine Rojas and Javier Rodrigues, and the tangos danced by Noelia Hurtado and Carlotos Espinoza, are classic examples."
ReplyDeleteThose are classic examples of show numbers from tango workers. Perhaps your point might be better illustrated by examples of real social dancing from regular dancers.
To Paul and Chris: Your points are well taken. But I decided to keep the video selections to illustrate that tango can be beautifully danced in close embrace, or at least mainly in close embrace, as it was created to and still should be danced whether socially or on stage. I am now incline more and more to the position that the embrace, as the single most important ingredient of tango (see my post The Thirteenth Pitfall of A Tanguera), should not be replaced by a cheap substitution, i.e., the open hold, for the dance to remain tango, even for exhibition purpose. The exhibitionism at the cost of the embrace is a bad trend in tango today.
ReplyDelete