October 28, 2015
The Age Prejudice in Tango
A few years ago, a friend of mine made a comment in a personal email after she read one of my blog articles. Although I've kept the content private out of respect for her concerns at the time, I think it’s now appropriate to “declassify” it. My last post, How to Get More Invitations in the Milongas, generated a call for discussion on the men’s role in the issue, which is exactly what her comment addresses. Here is her comment:
“I read your blog article with interest and agree with everything you say, but I'd like to comment on one aspect of behavior related to tango that you didn’t mention. I'm making this comment privately rather than publicly because, from bitter experience, I know how annoyed it makes men to hear what I think on this subject. It has to do with men’s attitudes at milongas regarding whom they choose to dance with—and men in Argentina are even worse than men in America about this.
Most men feel entitled to dance only with women they are personally attracted to and who, they think, will enhance their image. I can understand not wanting to dance with women who are poor dancers or unpleasant people, but this is seldom the case. Men tend to ignore women who aren’t sufficiently attractive or young, even if they are good dancers and even if they have friendly relationships with them. Women can sit out tanda after tanda, surrounded by men they know who otherwise treat them kindly, but who will ask every other woman around to dance while ignoring those they deem undesirable as romantic prospects or status symbols on the dance floor.
When this subject is broached, men often get very angry, or if a woman shows her disappointment while sitting alone, they resent the implication that they owe anyone anything or that they’ve failed in courtesy or generosity. Then they blame the women, calling them bad sports or accusing them of unfair demands. We're all taught that milongas are social gatherings, and the idea of the tango community is emphasized. Yet, while most women will dance with men they don’t particularly enjoy dancing with to be civil and avoid hurting anyone’s feelings, almost no men will go out of their way to help a woman enjoy herself at a milonga unless they personally want to dance with her. I think that the integrity and social concern you rightly address should include more compassion in partner choice.
At every milonga I've ever attended, I see women suffering silently as they sit unasked among friends and acquaintances, not to mention strangers, while young, attractive beginners are asked constantly. My own gray hair has put me in this position all too often, and in Buenos Aires, I was even told that if I wanted men to dance with me, I should dye my hair or wear a wig because men don’t want to be associated with aging women on the dance floor. This chronic macho selfishness is tango’s biggest drawback for women, and it’s a deep source of sorrow for more women than you might imagine.”
I have to admit, guilt washed over me as I read her comment, realizing that until then, I had never truly considered the depth of impact men's behavior—including my own—can have on women. While many view the milonga as a refuge, it is often a bittersweet space where men and women come together to tango, yet, too often, our enjoyment of the dance is hampered by our own prejudice, arrogance, and selfishness.
I can’t argue with human nature. Men are attracted to young, beautiful, and alluring women, just as women are drawn to young, handsome, and attractive men; and we all tango for pleasure. However, we must not let this instinct cloud our judgment. A tango partner is not a life partner. Whether they are young, pretty, or fertile is irrelevant. What matters is their knowledge, understanding, musicality, discernment, skills, and maturity as a tango dancer. These qualities take years, even decades, of dedicated study, practice, and education to cultivate. Tango is an adult dance. Most people take it up only after establishing a career or raising a family. By the time they truly understand it, they are no longer young. That is why milongueros and milongueras tend to be older, yet in the milongas of Buenos Aires, they are revered. Young Argentine dancers consider it an honor to share a tanda with them, and tango enthusiasts from around the world travel to Buenos Aires for the same privilege.
In the U.S., the first and second generations of tango dancers are now reaching their senior years, as the revival of tango that began in 1983 has spanned more than three decades. But unlike in Argentina, here senior dancers often face ageism. At a recent event I attended, out of over a hundred participants, about a dozen older women sat largely ignored. Encouraged by the organizer, I decided to dance with them—and it turned out to be a truly enriching experience. All these women were excellent dancers, with most having danced tango for more than ten years. This experience taught me a valuable lesson about the naivety of bias against older dancers.
I’m not suggesting that all older dancers are exceptional, nor do I advocate for “charity” dances. But I believe ageism in tango is unjustified, especially considering that older dancers often have significantly more experience than their younger counterparts—and that there are far more skilled tangueros and tangueras among older dancers than among younger ones. It’s in your own best interest to move beyond age-based judgments and to avoid conflating tango with courtship. In my experience, women in their fifties, sixties, and seventies are often among the finest social dancers. Younger men, in particular, shouldn’t miss the opportunity to dance with them.
Mature women may not appear as fresh or sexy as younger ones, but their embrace, connection, musicality, communication, and coordination are often far superior. Through years of practice, they have developed a deeper understanding of tango—something that younger dancers, lacking such experience, have yet to attain. This is especially true given how long it can take to overcome the social, cultural, ideological, and technical barriers that inhibit expressive dancing—something mature dancers are uniquely positioned to transcend. Dancing with them gives younger dancers access to an entirely new perspective on tango—an experience they should not miss. (See For Milongueras.)